I had mine in a monaco 'metal' case and dropped the phone, needless to say, the case is done.
I also use a Krussel Apollo pouch, so I'm back to that and now contemplating a seidio.
In another thread I was warning people about this case (monaco metal case). Just had really bad experiences with the case and the company both.
Right now I am using the Seidio Innocase but I always go back and forth considering going back to naked. I like the way the case feels and looks but naked is always nicer. I have a Waterfield suede jacket that I can use for it naked.
Plus I think I want to get it out of my pocket and wear it on my belt, for the lint reasons and SAR reasons but I haven't really found something suitable. I used the VZW belt clip with it naked for a while but if it bumps into something I tends to fall out. Was considering a leather pouch.