I have the body glove case and I think it's great. Only thing sucks with having a case is you have to take the case off if you use the docking station.
I'm using the 2 piece Body Glove one, I like it a lot. Some people are complaing about excessive heat with it. I have not experienced any heat issues, but I am not on the thing 24/7 making it work hard.
I purchased the Snap On Cover - Black Leather case from Verizon and had to return it the next day. It did not allow me to slide out the keyboard or put the phone in the dock. Terrible design on that case. I am still waiting for something that can be kept on while on the dock, however I think that is impossible.
I do not want anything with rubber, because I put my phone in my pocket often and it is a pain pulling it out with a rubber case...
