Alright I know this has been talked about in other threads but I could not find an actual answer to this problem. My problem is that when I try to reply to a text from the person with the blue arrow my phone opens up the contact with the red arrow. I do not know but I have a screen protector on could it be that? Also it doesn't matter which contacts are in these positions and it doesn't matter what messenger I use. I've used stock, chompSMS, and Handcent.