Maybe the location of his test was bias towards AT&T? I think overall people have tried both and VZW is better. So far VZW has been better for me. People with iphones use wifi in my building, my guess is because 3g doesn't work or doesn't work well for them.I don't understand why people don't get that. Coverage varies. Every carrier has holes. Everyone needs to assess carriers for their own individual coverage purposes. If you're getting the coverage you need that's all that matters.In my area, AT&T works better. I had Verizon for over 5 years. My son had AT&T. We did side by side tests with both. AT&T won. Now I must wait impatiently for the droid.