I'm a very tough critic. That said, this phone gets a very solid and extremely surprising 4. I was expecting much worse.
PROS: Superb browsing, great screen resolution, full featured web apps for running a web site, office and virtually anything you want. Email SUCKS but the surprising K-9 open source client just is the bomb. If you need something, chances are it's here and you just have to spend a significant time investment to put it together.
CONS: Still crashes far too often and lacks a true sense of reliability like the Blackberry and iPhone, especially things like voice/video recording. OS needs some work but Droid model lacks phone dock to quickly get to and from phone app, which is important. Third party apps solve this but will drain battery and slow down Droid a little. Battery life is truly dismal - I have brightness/contrast on the lowest setting and I still will barely get through the day with normal usage, iPhone certainly got better battery life. My guess is I'll get 2.5 hours of straight usage, perhaps only a little more, with the Internet. Talk time is much better than Internet usage. Keyboard SUCKED but incredibly, I actually found myself getting very good with the keyboard after a week.
Pros that make up for a lot of cons:
- Keyboard brilliantly has period, comma, question mark and @ key as instant keys, no shift required. Damned amazing and puts the BB to shame.
- Incredible resolution making PDF and docs and miniature web pages readable
- K9: Other than annoyance of backing in/out and memory issues from doing so, perhaps the best most full featured email client I've had since the Treo and Snappermail... this is close.
- OS and apps work better than most iPhone applications in terms of capabilities and extensibility. Yes, some of them are still first generation but being able to download docs, read in any application, manipulate docs -- I can get over some of the awkwardness.
The Droid needs work but at this point it's far more useful than the iPhone (great as a "read only" device for people who want a music player, a phone, PIM and a little more) and is the only touch screen/hi res device with a hardware keyboard (besting the BB which browsing is impossible for me.) I expected to give it a three. Solid four, I really like it after spending 30 days with it.