The reviews I've read tend to criticize the Incredible 4G because of the screen size. Otherwise, it's a great (little) phone. I like the size. I have the Rezound and got the Incredible 4G for my wife. If I had to replace my Rezound for some reason, I would definitely get a second Incredible 4G.
I agree...I think this phone got overlooked by the Samsung s3 as everyone was fighting over the large screen. If I wanted a large screen, I'd use my iPad.