I just got rid of my iPhone two days ago. Here's my take on the ups and downs of moving to the droid:
The good:
- The screen is absolutely gorgeous. The pixels are so dense that I can read websites without zooming in at all.
- The physical keyboard is awesome. I spend a lot of time typing emails, mostly work related, and work involves a lot of acronyms and terminology that doesn't show up in the touchscreen keyboard's dictionary. It's good to have a keyboard that doesn't second guess me
- I like how the OS doesn't treat me like I'm a little kid. The iPhone's OS is pretty user friendly, but I think it's also patronizing. The fact that I couldn't use my phone as a USB drive, and the fact that I could only sync it with one computer really irritated me.
- Verizon has better coverage than at&t, and it doesn't drop every third call. Yes, my iphone was dropping one out of three calls. Maybe it's the phone, maybe it's att, but at this point I could care less, since I let my dollars do the talking.
The bad:
- The Droid's UI is choppier. While the iPhone 3g, and especially the 3gs have excellent framerates for UI animations, android is much choppier. Maybe it's because the Droid's screen has that many more pixels, but it's something Motorola or Google may want to look at optimizing.
- The built in apps seem to lack polish. Just look at the gallery app, or the music player, or even the browser. They work fine, but they don't work nearly as well as their counterparts on the iPhone.
- The Droid is just worse for music and video in general. Say what you will about iTunes, but it is a centralized place where all your music and videos are. You can simply drag and drop your media on your phone. All the while, video playing on the Droid is quite literally an afterthought because it has no built in video player (that I can find)
Overall, I think that divorcing at&t and paying out the early termination alimony was worth it. The iPhone is a solid platform, with a lot of apps, but none of the apps, downloadable or built in, were good at doing the four things I need to do the most: calling, emails, texts, and browsing. Calls were dropped constantly, emails had to be tapped on glass, texts were in this cutsy, but featureless "speech-bubble" interface that had time stamps every 2 hours, and browsing had to be done on a network that barely worked, if ever. I'd seriously be looking at the spinner next to the "3g" emblem on the iPhone for entire minutes waiting for sites to load, and that was with full bars.
As for the Droid, it's just about everything that I could have wanted in a phone. I'm not worried about things like video playing, and a choppy browser because I have alternative applications I can download. This is simply not true for the iPhone, where no 3rd party apps can compete with the 1st party features. Where the hell was this phone last summer, when I decided to take the plunge with the iPhone?