I tried a few ways:
1) I tried to use Clockwork Mod, went into "Install rom from sd card", scrolled down to download folder, selected rom. After doing that in Clockwork a window pops up giving you options before installing new rom. I checked "backup existing rom", "clear dalvic", and "wipe data and cache". The phone resets and goes eight back to where i was.
2) Using Bootstrap the phone just resets back to where it was instead of going into the recovery screen. I tried reinstalling and even purchased the paid version but nothing made a difference.
3) I manually held the both volume keys while booting up the phone to get into recovery. The screen it brings is kinda different than I'm used to though. The only options are: "reboot system", "reboot from sd card", "wipe cache", "wipe all user data". When i go into reboot from sd card it shows all the folders on my sd card but no files. It will even let me go into each folder and their sub folders but still wont show files.
I had read somewhere that when verizon rolled out 5.9.902 it disabled root. I still show the superuser app and everything in it has permissions but it seems like all of my programs that need root don't work.