It says no longer include gapps 4 legal reasons, what reasons could they be? If it's personal I understand but just curious cause I've never seen that before
Sent from My Simply Stunning Droid using Tapatalk
The legal reasons are that technically, any ROM includes proprietary files that are NOT licensed for re-release. These include google files as well as the various proprietaries from motorola (or other device manufacturers depending on the device). While each individual user has a right to possess and utilize these pieces of software on their phones, nobody officially has a right to re-distribute them.
Sapphire has taken the initiative to provide google apps separately, as Cyanogen has received a Cease and Desist from google in the past, and that is what they were asked to do. This may or may not prevent google from contacting us about this in the future, as technically we are still redistributing the google apps, and don't have a written agreement or anything, as I would suspect cyanogen does, but it is a good faith effort to show that we are not here to steal anyone's work illegally.
This brings up the lingering issue of device manufacturer proprietaries. Technically, sapphire's build is set up in such a way that if motorola, htc, etc. ever DID give a C&D about their software, we could rip it out and provide a method to circumvent it, though it would be a hard blow to the ROM community, as no ROM will actually run properly without those files.
All in all it is important to understand that technically we are playing with the intellectual property of others when developing these ROMs, and although companies like motorola have gotten a lot of flack for their bootloader lockdowns, they have been surprisingly lax on enforcing the distribution of their proprietary software.
Anyway, I've rambled on long enough about this. That is essentially what we mean by "legal matters". I hope that shed some light on the situation.