I agree with moset. Give gsam some time to make more accurate readings.
In regards to auto brightness and battery saver, that is the best way to go. However, consider the environment that you are in. If you are in a brightly lit room all the time and/or outside in the sun, then brightness is going to default to the higher levels and still use a lot of battery. As an alternative, you can change from auto brightness to around a 30% setting and leave the battery saver box checked. It will work great for overall indoor use but not outside in the sun.
Also, look in your widgets for the Motorola power control widget. It lets you cycle through the screen brightness settings without having to go into settings. I use it whenever I go outside to set my screen to max brightness and then back to auto when I go inside. Works great and saves lots of steps.
Finally, Consider other things running in the background that consume lots of battery such as facebook, any app that syncs or uploads photos, weather apps that constantly update and the gmail widget (not the app). All of those especially the gmail widget proved to be huge battery hogs on my phone.
You may also want to consider leaving wifi on all the time. For me it seems like my battery life is actually better when I leave wifi on.
David