Google's Eric Schimdt: Says Android is Differentiation Not Fragmentation

dgstorm

Editor in Chief
Staff member
Premium Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2010
Messages
10,991
Reaction score
3,961
Location
Austin, TX
eric-schmidt-ces-2012.jpg

One could argue that Eric Schmidt of Google is living in denial about the "fragmentation" of Android, but he also makes some persuasive arguments to the contrary. He recently came forward at CES indicating that there isn't really a problem of fragmentation on Android. He claims that the platform instead offers customer-friendly "differentiation." He sees differentiation as a positive and fragmentation as a negative, and elaborated that if there were fragmentation then apps would be far more broken across the differing versions of Android, and different third party skins of Android.

He further shared, “Differentiation means that you have a choice and the people who are making the phones, they’re going to compete on their view of innovation. They’re going to try and convince you that theirs is better than somebody else.” He added, “We absolutely allow [manufacturers] to add or change the user interface as long as they don’t break the apps.” Schmidt concluded with, “What people really care about is if there’s an interoperable ecosystem of apps” instead of every device having the same UI.

In fact, you can see Google somewhat working to balance this with Ice Cream Sandwich. Any device that manufacturers want to have ICS, and still be able to get Android Market access, must support the Holo theme. While this is a slight tightening of controls, it merely means that Holo must be available to any apps that call upon it, and that manufacturers won’t be able to release devices that solely offer their own theme and not Google’s default in order to still gain access to the Android Market.

On an interesting side-note, Mr. Schmidt took some time to share his views on all the Apple lawsuits and injunctions against Samsung, and a little about Windows Phone. Here were his comments, "Apple works very hard to block choice in Germany by trying to prevent Samsung tablets [from becoming] available. That's called prevention of choice." He made the argument that consumers should instead be able to judge all products fairly; "it's called competition." In regards to Windows Phone he said, "Microsoft's trapped in an architectural transition problem they may not get through."

Source: SlashGear
 

czerdrill

Silver Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
4,825
Reaction score
12
eric-schmidt-ces-2012.jpg

One could argue that Eric Schmidt of Google is living in denial about the "fragmentation" of Android, but he also makes some persuasive arguments to the contrary. He recently came forward at CES indicating that there isn't really a problem of fragmentation on Android. He claims that the platform instead offers customer-friendly "differentiation." He sees differentiation as a positive and fragmentation as a negative, and elaborated that if there were fragmentation then apps would be far more broken across the differing versions of Android, and different third party skins of Android.

He further shared, “Differentiation means that you have a choice and the people who are making the phones, they’re going to compete on their view of innovation. They’re going to try and convince you that theirs is better than somebody else.” He added, “We absolutely allow [manufacturers] to add or change the user interface as long as they don’t break the apps.” Schmidt concluded with, “What people really care about is if there’s an interoperable ecosystem of apps” instead of every device having the same UI.

In fact, you can see Google somewhat working to balance this with Ice Cream Sandwich. Any device that manufacturers want to have ICS, and still be able to get Android Market access, must support the Holo theme. While this is a slight tightening of controls, it merely means that Holo must be available to any apps that call upon it, and that manufacturers won’t be able to release devices that solely offer their own theme and not Google’s default in order to still gain access to the Android Market.

On an interesting side-note, Mr. Schmidt took some time to share his views on all the Apple lawsuits and injunctions against Samsung, and a little about Windows Phone. Here were his comments, "Apple works very hard to block choice in Germany by trying to prevent Samsung tablets [from becoming] available. That's called prevention of choice." He made the argument that consumers should instead be able to judge all products fairly; "it's called competition." In regards to Windows Phone he said, "Microsoft's trapped in an architectural transition problem they may not get through."

Source: SlashGear

Haha well what else would he say? They've gone from denying it exists to now saying its a positive. Tell that to the people still waiting for ICS or in some cases GB haha....fragmentation goes beyond just different UIs...
 

Burnicus

New Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
27
Reaction score
0
Living in a fantasy world

After moving from Moto to HTC recently, I can say that Schmidt is clueless.
 

droidxd00d

Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2011
Messages
244
Reaction score
8
I wish makers were required to allow users to "turn off" their skins so every device could run vanilla android without rooting and installing roms.

Sent from my DROID BIONIC using DroidForums
 

Stelv

Silver Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2010
Messages
2,650
Reaction score
8
Location
Western NY
Schmidt is not clueless, he is a shady businessman and will say only positive things about his business. We all know fragmentation is a BIG problem, you aren't pulling the wool over anyones eyes Schmidt. No device should be below Gingerbread at this point, manufacturers should offer updates past 6 months...blah blah...fragmentation is REAL! I can't wait for the next big OS (it's not iOS) to come along and knock Schmidt off his high horse.

Nice picture by the way, goes great with the article:biggrin:
 

kptphalkon

Active Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2010
Messages
1,380
Reaction score
6
Is he suggesting that a customizable interface is worth more than platform stability? This man is clearly out of his mind.
 
OP
dgstorm

dgstorm

Editor in Chief
Staff member
Premium Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2010
Messages
10,991
Reaction score
3,961
Location
Austin, TX
Schmidt is not clueless, he is a shady businessman and will say only positive things about his business. We all know fragmentation is a BIG problem, you aren't pulling the wool over anyones eyes Schmidt. No device should be below Gingerbread at this point, manufacturers should offer updates past 6 months...blah blah...fragmentation is REAL! I can't wait for the next big OS (it's not iOS) to come along and knock Schmidt off his high horse.

Nice picture by the way, goes great with the article:biggrin:

Thanks. I thought the picture fit his "unique" perspective on this subject as well. I did like what he had to say regarding the Apple lawsuits. His comments were not surprising, but still interesting.
 

Stelv

Silver Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2010
Messages
2,650
Reaction score
8
Location
Western NY
What do you think Schmidt meant when he said Windows was trapped in a Architectural Transition? What does that mean exactly?
 
OP
dgstorm

dgstorm

Editor in Chief
Staff member
Premium Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2010
Messages
10,991
Reaction score
3,961
Location
Austin, TX
What do you think Schmidt meant when he said Windows was trapped in a Architectural Transition? What does that mean exactly?

It's a special marketing dialect that is spoken only by ex-CEOs in order to confuse their prey just long enough to pounce on them!
 
OP
dgstorm

dgstorm

Editor in Chief
Staff member
Premium Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2010
Messages
10,991
Reaction score
3,961
Location
Austin, TX
Is he suggesting that a customizable interface is worth more than platform stability? This man is clearly out of his mind.

I have to agree. I like optimistic attitudes, but his head is way in the clouds on this one.
 

Snow02

Active Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2011
Messages
1,339
Reaction score
9
Schmidt is not clueless, he is a shady businessman and will say only positive things about his business. We all know fragmentation is a BIG problem, you aren't pulling the wool over anyones eyes Schmidt. No device should be below Gingerbread at this point, manufacturers should offer updates past 6 months...blah blah...fragmentation is REAL! I can't wait for the next big OS (it's not iOS) to come along and knock Schmidt off his high horse.

Nice picture by the way, goes great with the article:biggrin:

No, we don't all know fragmentation is a problem. I'd challenge you to cite some examples.
 

Stelv

Silver Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2010
Messages
2,650
Reaction score
8
Location
Western NY
No, we don't all know fragmentation is a problem. I'd challenge you to cite some examples.

-Certain apps not working on certain phones. For example my Bionic is very capable, but certain apps are not "compatible" with my device. Phones systems are fragmented.
-A lot phones are still stuck on 2.2 with no update in site.
-Phones can be released half finished because the set of Android standards from Google is low
-Carriers can force skins and bloat onto devices even if the manufacturer may not want them there
...there are more I am sure.
 

rherron

Member
Joined
Jul 1, 2011
Messages
294
Reaction score
5
Schmidt is not clueless, he is a shady businessman and will say only positive things about his business. We all know fragmentation is a BIG problem, you aren't pulling the wool over anyones eyes Schmidt. No device should be below Gingerbread at this point, manufacturers should offer updates past 6 months...blah blah...fragmentation is REAL! I can't wait for the next big OS (it's not iOS) to come along and knock Schmidt off his high horse.

Nice picture by the way, goes great with the article:biggrin:

My work-issued Droid Titanium (less than 8 months old) on Sprint (I know) runs Eclair. I'm hoping for Froyo on that piece of crap. It's hard to step down and use it when my personal device is a RAXR.
 
Top