first time customers only or can upgrade costumers get this deal as well?
They can't do upgrade customers. I tried the first week of the program. Verizon has prevented Best Buy's system from doing early upgrades for customers.
The only option would be to get a new line & cancel your existing line and pay whatever early termination fee you owe.
I'm still contemplating, but I'm not certain how worthwhile it is with the math.
My situation is this.
Early termination fee = $150
Return restocking fee for the Fascinate I just purchased = $30
New line & activation of new line = $30
New "free" Fascinate on new line = $0
Total cost to get a "free" Fascinate = $210
vs.
New Fascinate with early upgrade = $299
Early upgrade rebate = -$100
Early upgrade fee = $20
Total cost for early upgrade Fascinate = $219
So basically, I save $9 but i'm stuck with a new phone number that I have to distribute to EVERYONE I know basically...a number i've had for going on 10 years now.