a phone is limited to its network. and for my area, att is second rate.
The first person to reply to that thread has a rotory engine as his avatar...I mean c'mon, how bright is he?
i know for a fact that if droid were to pull all its phones from verizon, and offer them solely on att, i would not switch back. thats how badly i view the att network. fwiw, im a residential contractor, so my phone must be a phone first. anything extra, is kickass. if my phone cant make phone calls, or if my network doesnt consider replacing damaged towers after a hurricane to be of utmost importance, there is no phone fancy enough to get me to stay on their network. my only hope is that verizon doesnt lose sight of this.
Seeing as this is the #1 concern for most users of cell phones, i don't think verizon is going to go crazy and not have the coverage it needs.
Its all about preferences...a users needs. Not solely on who sucks and who doesnt.
Its just like the Windows/Mac battle. There is no winner that can take all. They both do what they need to do. One just may do it better per that users experience and needs. What they value as "cool".
Thats why we have different foods...different clothes. I hate carrots...my wife loves them. Doesn't mean carrots are the devil. Either is the iPhone.
If the iPhone hadn't come out...would Motorola have had such a push to come out with the droid? I think not. To each his own....