Feedback on AMOLED to “Super TFT”

rsarno

Member
Joined
May 25, 2010
Messages
173
Reaction score
0
I am reading about HTC switching to the “Super TFT” for the Incredible in order to meet demands.

Can anyone chime in with hands-on experience with the differences? Will there be a noticeable difference in quality, or in direct sunlight?

Thanks, any feedback would be great
 

Durango_Boy

Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2010
Messages
57
Reaction score
0
Location
Columbia, MO
I am reading about HTC switching to the “Super TFT” for the Incredible in order to meet demands.

Can anyone chime in with hands-on experience with the differences? Will there be a noticeable difference in quality, or in direct sunlight?

Thanks, any feedback would be great


Sadly I think the Super AMOLED is the better of the two options. Problem is that Samsung, who makes those displays, is pulling them from all non-Samsung phones. It's a highly specific display that would be hard to legally make another way.

Hence Super TFT. It'll be very close to the Super AMOLED display, but it won't have the same direct sunlight capability due to the extra layers in the design of the display.

I don't think it'll be something we'll be disappointed with.
 

mach330

Active Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2009
Messages
762
Reaction score
48
Location
The OC
what is the diff on the super TFT vs regular LCD's (not the AMOLED)? are any phones using super TFT?
 

NickF

New Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2010
Messages
24
Reaction score
0
AMOLED screens don't require a backlight and are therefore much thinner and more power efficient than standard TFT-LCD designs. Samsung's panels offer great brightness and clarity, even in sunlight. Now, I'm not sure what exact panels HTC has chosen as a successor. However, I'm sure picture quality might not be drastically changed, but it will certainly use more power and will more than likely make the phone a bit thicker because of the required back-lighting, even if they use low power LEDs to do so.
 

kmo

Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2010
Messages
537
Reaction score
2
Most won't know the difference between the two.
 

NickF

New Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2010
Messages
24
Reaction score
0
Sure, but the educated power users that this forum tailors to will be left in the dark.
 

zMd113

Member
Joined
May 27, 2010
Messages
365
Reaction score
0
Location
OKC
The only difference I notice is when I'm outside and I can see what's on the screen without putting my hand over it to see. I actually do that sometimes out of habit but I really don't need too lol. Other than that I can't tell any difference.
 

kmo

Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2010
Messages
537
Reaction score
2
Sure, but the educated power users that this forum tailors to will be left in the dark.
Is there really a big difference in battery drain between the two? I don't think so, amoled might be more efficient but I doubt it's significant.
 

Ironric75

New Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2010
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Hey guys Im new to this forum but i can with 90% percent certainty confirm your fears that the incredible has switched to super tft screens. I recived a replacement phone today from verizon, because my speaker blew out on my old one. When i started up the new phone i noticed the display looked different i promptly put my battery back in my old phone to confirm this and the difference is quite noticeable.In the short time that i used the new phone i noticed this difference is most obvious in the slide to unlock screen and when you bring up the keyboard.where on my original phone the slide to unlock was a rich black on the new phone its a light gray the new screen is comparable to the htc hero screen. needless to say Im going to a Verizon store to confront them about this. If Im getting a downgraded phone i want some kind of compensation because the beautiful aomled screen was the tipping point for me. If Verizon refuses to come to a deal with me, Im torn between keeping my current phone with the aomled and a blown speak(it still works but sounds distorted) or making the change and sticking with the tft display. its a tough call
 

2010 ZR1

Member
Joined
May 22, 2010
Messages
105
Reaction score
0
Hey guys Im new to this forum but i can with 90% percent certainty confirm your fears that the incredible has switched to super tft screens. I recived a replacement phone today from verizon, because my speaker blew out on my old one. When i started up the new phone i noticed the display looked different i promptly put my battery back in my old phone to confirm this and the difference is quite noticeable.In the short time that i used the new phone i noticed this difference is most obvious in the slide to unlock screen and when you bring up the keyboard.where on my original phone the slide to unlock was a rich black on the new phone its a light gray the new screen is comparable to the htc hero screen. needless to say Im going to a Verizon store to confront them about this. If Im getting a downgraded phone i want some kind of compensation because the beautiful aomled screen was the tipping point for me. If Verizon refuses to come to a deal with me, Im torn between keeping my current phone with the aomled and a blown speak(it still works but sounds distorted) or making the change and sticking with the tft display. its a tough call

If the screen is the main reason you bought the phone, you may be interested in one of the new Samsung phones that have S-AMOLED screens. Just because the blacks aren't 100% black doesn't mean you have to throw a fit. You might be able though, to request that they put you on a 30 day waiting list again to get a phone where things that black are a deep black, instead of just black.
 

Ironric75

New Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2010
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Hey guys Im new to this forum but i can with 90% percent certainty confirm your fears that the incredible has switched to super tft screens. I recived a replacement phone today from verizon, because my speaker blew out on my old one. When i started up the new phone i noticed the display looked different i promptly put my battery back in my old phone to confirm this and the difference is quite noticeable.In the short time that i used the new phone i noticed this difference is most obvious in the slide to unlock screen and when you bring up the keyboard.where on my original phone the slide to unlock was a rich black on the new phone its a light gray the new screen is comparable to the htc hero screen. needless to say Im going to a Verizon store to confront them about this. If Im getting a downgraded phone i want some kind of compensation because the beautiful aomled screen was the tipping point for me. If Verizon refuses to come to a deal with me, Im torn between keeping my current phone with the aomled and a blown speak(it still works but sounds distorted) or making the change and sticking with the tft display. its a tough call

If the screen is the main reason you bought the phone, you may be interested in one of the new Samsung phones that have S-AMOLED screens. Just because the blacks aren't 100% black doesn't mean you have to throw a fit. You might be able though, to request that they put you on a 30 day waiting list again to get a phone where things that black are a deep black, instead of just black.

Really? That's good news I haven't heard of this list is it through HTC or Verizon ? If you can give me some info on it that'd be great 30 days is totally worth it for deep black colors
 

RETG

Active Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2010
Messages
673
Reaction score
119
Location
West of the Tetons, East of the Sawtooths
Current Phone Model
Samsung S22 Ultra
Sure, but the educated power users that this forum tailors to will be left in the dark.
Is there really a big difference in battery drain between the two? I don't think so, amoled might be more efficient but I doubt it's significant.

For blacks and color, they will consume less power than a LCD; however, when displaying white, they actually consume more power than a LCD. Therefoe, overall, there is a small advantage.
 
Top