Does wifi use less energy than 3g?

rdgxray

Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2011
Messages
192
Reaction score
1
Should I have smart actions turn on my wifi when at home? Will this use less battery? I usually only connect to my wifi if downloading or web surfing. Keep it off and on 3g most the time. If it makes sense to turn on wifi, will keeping smart actions active to turn wifi on and off causes some drain battery? Does it use gps to tell when you are home? Don't want gps on all the time. Anyone use smart actions to turn wifi on and off when changing locations? How does it work for you?

Sent from my DROID RAZR using DroidForums
 

cece5702

Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2011
Messages
929
Reaction score
16
I use Smart Actions with Wi-Fi and it works great at saving battery.

Sent from my DROID RAZR MAXX
 

Zandar

Active Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2010
Messages
523
Reaction score
34
Wifi has to be on for locations with Smart Actions. Wifi does use less power than either 3G or 4G, but it drains battery if you leave it on when not in use because it will constantly search for a signal. Best bet is to turn it on when you're in range of wifi and turn it of all other times (use the power control widget).

As for the GPS, I've found there's so little difference in power draw that it's not worth it to leave it off or set a Smart Action to disable it. I had no battery gain leaving it off, but it would take forever to get a fix those times when I needed to use navigation or some other such thing. In my opinion, leave the GPS antenna on. The same can't be said for wifi; leaving it on when it's not in use kills your battery.

Sliced from my RAZR
 

Axium

Member
Joined
May 30, 2010
Messages
206
Reaction score
0
When you say not in use you mean not connected to a network yes? Or connected but idle in one..as in not downloading or netflix

Sent from my GALAXY NEXUS using DroidForums
 

guidot

Developer Relations
Staff member
Premium Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2010
Messages
7,292
Reaction score
272
Location
Massachusetts
When you say not in use you mean not connected to a network yes? Or connected but idle in one..as in not downloading or netflix

Sent from my GALAXY NEXUS using DroidForums

As in on but not connected to a wireless network.

Sent from my XT862 + ICS
 

FoxKat

Premium Member
Premium Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2010
Messages
14,655
Reaction score
4,720
Location
Pennsylvania
Current Phone Model
Droid Turbo 2 & Galaxy S7
Should I have smart actions turn on my wifi when at home? Will this use less battery? I usually only connect to my wifi if downloading or web surfing. Keep it off and on 3g most the time. If it makes sense to turn on wifi, will keeping smart actions active to turn wifi on and off causes some drain battery? Does it use gps to tell when you are home? Don't want gps on all the time. Anyone use smart actions to turn wifi on and off when changing locations? How does it work for you?

Sent from my DROID RAZR using DroidForums

Wifi has to be on for locations with Smart Actions. Wifi does use less power than either 3G or 4G, but it drains battery if you leave it on when not in use because it will constantly search for a signal. Best bet is to turn it on when you're in range of wifi and turn it of all other times (use the power control widget).

As for the GPS, I've found there's so little difference in power draw that it's not worth it to leave it off or set a Smart Action to disable it. I had no battery gain leaving it off, but it would take forever to get a fix those times when I needed to use navigation or some other such thing. In my opinion, leave the GPS antenna on. The same can't be said for wifi; leaving it on when it's not in use kills your battery.

Sliced from my RAZR

Zandar is correct regarding power consumption of WIFI versus 3G or 4G based on my own evaluations as well. It is conceivable that if you have a poor WIFI signal and a good 3G, you may acutally use less power with the 3G than with the WIFI, but at the very least you may alos get better speeds with the 3G. Since 3G is on all the time, that may be one reason for NOT using WIFI in spots that the serivce is poor.

But Zandar also makes one crucial point regarding Smart Actions location based actions in that they will not work without WIFI on, so I found a simple solution for those faced with that dilemma. Download and install Verizon WIFI Auto On. Then set locations on the Verizon app that have known WIFI available to you, such as "Home", "Work", "Starbucks", "Library", etc. Then when you are nearing or within range of those hotspots, Verizon WIFI Auto On will trigger WIFI for you.

This will allow any Smart Actions that are location based to function normally, and since you can then be specific to create only location based actions that will operate in those hotspot zones, you will have effectively worked around that problem. When you leave those locations, a short time later the Auto On tool will turn WIFI off, conserving battery for you.

For me it's cut the use of the battery considerably during the day when I am no where near a known hotspot.

Finally, thank you Zandar for the very enlightening information regarding GPS. I wouldn't have drawn that conclusion myself and rather than testing I simply kept GPS off. Now with your advice I am going to give it a try for a few days and leave it running to see if it has any significant effect on my battery life. I would certainly rather leave it on all the time if I knew it wasn't a resource hog. ;)
 
Last edited:

FoxKat

Premium Member
Premium Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2010
Messages
14,655
Reaction score
4,720
Location
Pennsylvania
Current Phone Model
Droid Turbo 2 & Galaxy S7
As in on but not connected to a wireless network.

Sent from my XT862 + ICS

Correct, just on but not connected. Also it doesn't matter if its in range of WIFI or not. It's constantly looking for any new networks available. It can notify of new networks as they come into range so it therefore has to be searching for them all the time. This is what eats up power.
 

Trash Can

Active Member
Joined
Jun 25, 2010
Messages
339
Reaction score
25
Location
Las Vegas, NV
Finally, thank you Zandar for the very enlightening information regarding GPS. I wouldn't have drawn that conclusion myself and rather than testing I simply kept GPS off. Now with your advice I am going to give it a try for a few days and leave it running to see if it has any significant effect on my battery life. I would certainly rather leave it on all the time if I knew it wasn't a resource hog. ;)

FWIW, I concur with Zandar. I leave my GPS on and do not notice any appreciable battery drain.
 
Top