I got the Golla bag because I am outdoors a lot and I really dug it on the site. I have a Motorola Droid, and it fits very snug inside the bag. It didn't fit with the extended battery, but I ditched that battery anyway because it doubled the size of my phone. I don't mind a hip case, besides, when I'm hiking I want to make sure it's hidden from branches but easily accessible if I want it. It's on sale right now too, a few bucks saved is a few bucks. Just adding my two cents...