Browsing with Atrix "4G" slower than D1 3G

Discussion in 'Android General Discussions' started by yiannis, Mar 17, 2011.

  1. yiannis

    yiannis Member

    Nov 22, 2009
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    People's obsession with the application is I think missing the fact that their speeds are often not the major factor deciding how fast the webpage loads.

    These tests have been conducted in parallel in the same area:

    My D1 @800 Mhz speedtest average: ~700kbps
    Colleague's Dx stock: ~1.5kbps
    Colleague's Atrix stock: ~1.4kbps

    Real web-browsing results for many websites (nytimes, huffingtonpost, drudgerepport,,, and many others:

    If we set the fastest experience to 100% here are the results:

    Dx Stock ROM and browser: 100%
    D1 BB 0.6.2 and xScope Pro browser: 90%
    Atrix stock ROM and browser:60%

    These may be perceived changes but the differences on many webpages in the course of 4 days inside a large building in Baltimore, MD, were painfully consistent.

    "Painfully" because of this dialog with the colleague who asked for advice 10 days ago:

    Colleague: Which do you think is the best phone coming in the next two weeks:
    Me: Atrix, no question
    Me: However, it is on AT&T so if I were you I would wait go to their store and test it when it arrives
    Colleague: It's not a problem I already have AT&T and they're good
    Me: Well its specifications are amazing but the best phones will come in Q2 and Q3 of this year if you can wait for a few months

  2. kodiak799

    kodiak799 Gold Member

    Feb 20, 2010
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    LTE blows it all away. I'm interested to see real world tests, but besides being supposedly 2X as fast as Sprint WiMax and 3-4X as fast as HSPA+, it also penetrates buildings better (horizontally and vertically).

    This is one time I'm definitely go to take advantage of the 14-day trial period. If I get the gains I expect (my 3G is terribly slow and inconsistent, not to mention the D1 is just too underpowered) it will be worth it to pay retail.