Scarecrow wasn't bad for a B and W?! (black and white fool)
Lol'd hard at the mention of ThanksKilling... watched that on instant queue. Besides the extreme boob closeup to start the film (best opening scene ever), that movie was painfull... Which is on purpose I guess. But if your going for best worst horror movie... the award goes to Troll 2.... no question (also, on Netflix Instant.. check it out... you won't be disapointed)....
As for actual good horrors.. I love all the classics.. Freddy, Jason, Michael, Leatherface etc... The Shining is probably my all time fav... All these new remakes are pretty lame (Omen, NMOES etc.)... The new trend of torture porn horror is just allright, I prefer scary to gross.
GO RED WINGS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!