Push Ads Warning

[calguy19]

There seems to be a new practice with some of the developers. They put "push ads" into their apps. These things work behind the scenes, after you close the app (still runs as a process, which you can't stop. They keep restarting). They put spam ads on your notification bar, including porno ads.

Check out "Restaurant Nutrition" app on the android market, and read the comments.

In general, you won't know which of your apps (new, or update) is putting those ads on your notification bar. You want your kid getting porno ads? Do YOU want to be bombarded with those ads, porno, or otherwise, and nothing you can do to stop them, short of deleting ALL your non-paid for apps?

These are in additon to those other push ads, loud 15-30 second videos that some adware apps suddenly launch (see the comments on the Weatherbug app, you can't turn down the volume. But at least you know which app is doing this, and you can complain to the developer and delete the app. With status bar push apps, you don't even know which app is doing it).

We need to complain to google and android market. They need to stop any apps which push ads to your phone surrepticiously from being placed on the market. This could be a problem for the entire google/droid phone market - if I can't download apps from them which won't hijack my phone, my next phone will be an Apple - they screen all apps going into their market.

[allenjgoldstein]

Are there any apps to detect these?

[nu2droid]

I hear ya. My wife had one on her d2g. Annoying as hell. Never could figure out which app did it.
Ended up doing a factory reset, it was the only way to get rid of it.
Hers was a yellow star icon that would show up in the notification bar saying she won an IPad. When you clicked it, it took you to a website that wouldn't even come up..
Something should be done.

Sent from my DROID3 using DroidForums

[sos567656765]

addons detector will scan your apps and tell you what ones use what ad systems. also airpush permanent opt out supposedly will keep you from getting any more.

I personally use a combination of addons detector (to see what apps misbehave), adfree (to block known ad servers) and droidwall (to only give apps that i trust access to the internet.) Ever since i started using droidwall and ad free my phone is virtually well... adfree.

[nu2droid]

I rely on adfree also, but somehow that damn star got past it and wouldnt get blocked.
Will have to try the others.

Sent from my DROID3 using DroidForums

[calguy19]

After I started this thread, there was an update on "Restaurant Nutrition" on the droid market. All the comments were one star - the update started pushing porno ad spam onto the notif bar. I also posted a nasty comment on the market, and send them a really nasty email (complete with several instances of the f-word). They backed off and issued an update, supposedly without any notif bar ads.

I also emailed Lookout and requested they include these kinds of push ads in their phone protection app. They emailed back saying they are aware of the problem and are working on it.

So far, they way I track these down is to suspect recently added apps or updates, see which ones run in the background (I use advanced task killer), and eliminate them one by one or in small groups, and see which ones absence makes the ads go away. If you get multiple apps sending these, it's much harder to track down the culprits.

Apps that do this will completely poison the well for all droid apps. If google doesn't put a stop to this, they could wind up destroying their own app marketplace, while I and many others simply migrate over to iphones.

QUESTION - How do you do airpush permanant opt-out?

[silverfang77]

This is one of the negative reprisals of having an anything-goes Market environment. It's great that Android devs have more freedom than Apple devs, but a few rogues are going to end up ruining it for everyone.

[calguy19]

There are reprisors and reprisees. Google could get themselves in real trouble if they don't deal with this. Look what happened to Netflix when they were stupid enough not to realize why their customers are there in the first place. Netfix's loss is Redbox's gain. If the google android market becomes littered with apps that secretly hijack your phone, push porno ads, contribute to identify theft, push loud vieeo popups you can't trun off, how long is going to be before most of us tell google where to go, and jump on the iphone bandwagon? Me - I have no intention of continuing with a smart phone system that behaves so obnoxiously.

Google - you better wake up.

[rubiksc00p]

So has anyone tried Airpush detector? I didn't see it mentioned. Just wanted to make sure you knew about it. It's great and lets you know which apps are causing the problem!

[zacedward]

Air pusher detector is really good it says which one is causing it

Sent from my ADR6400L using DroidForums