I ended up with the Steinheil. It took < 5 min to put one on mine...no bubbles or dust. I really like it.
I tried putting the second one on my wife's phone and the one edge was just a hair too close to the lip of the screen, so it had long area of no adhesion. When I pulled it up a bunch of dust got on the film. I can't seem to get it all off either. I'll try some of the washing methods I saw on other forums. if that doesn't work I'll order another set. When applied correctly, they are crystal clear and you can't tell they are on there.