I had a similar incident with my Droid 1 way back. It was a defective digitizer. The guy at tech support said it might have been related to the screen protector that I had recurrently removed.
That was never confirmed and in fact disputed by others but it started just after removal. The phone had to be replaced.
I never put another screen protector on. No scratches even now.
Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk