Seidio Innocase Active vs. Surface

[sorduj_88]

I'm deciding between the Seidio Innocase Active and II Surface. I really like the Surface because of it's size, but I've heard about squeaking, melting in heat, and the sides of the phone getting scratched because of installing/removing the case.

Those who have had the Surface for more than a couple months, have you had any issues? I'd rather hear from those who have had the case for a while say it's great instead of those who have had it for a day and say its great. I really want this case because of its small size, I just dont want it to have any of the above issues.

The Active seems really good too. I just dont want something too bulky and I dont know that I need that much protection, but has anyone had any issues with it after a while?

Thanks

[andrew_ja]

I own and use the Active case and I love it. I don't think it adds too much bulk, in fact I am fond of it. I makes the phone feel sturdier. Everyone also compliments the case that owns an Android phone wishing there was one for theirs.

I haven't seen the Surface in real life so I can't compare the two.

[Andrew C]

I have the Innocase Surface II on my Droid now. I am very satisfied with it and haven't experienced any issues. It never scratched my Droid, never melted, no squeaks, and it offers great protection. I would say that it adds some amount of bulk, but that's a matter of preference.

Edit: I've had the case since last October and it has been removed multiple times with no ill effects.

[MiXoLoGiSt]

I have both and got to say they are both great cases. And I've had both over a month. Got each on the days they were released.

Sent from my HTC Incredible using Tapatalk

[sorduj_88]

MiXoLoGiSt, any preference to either? if so, any specific reason?

[Logan176]

I went with the Active because I liked how the hard, snap-on cover went over the thin silicone piece. It's a very sturdy feeling cover. It slides into your pocket well, but it does collect a little bit of fuzzies where the silicone is exposed... not too much though. I also went with this one because the Innocase Surface II had that large seam across the back. However, that case is slimmer and probably doesn't attract the fuzzies.

All in all it seems like they are both good cases and I think it really comes down to your own preference on how each case looks. I did a lot of research before buying from Seidio and it seems like they are a good company.

[sorduj_88]

Thanks for your answers. I just ordered the Surface. The large seam might bother me, but I dont think I need the added protection of the Active, and I really want to keep it as small as possible. Just hope I dont have problems like I read on some reviews.. like squeaking and scratching the sides.

[Shankster]

Active with holster. Love it !

[Prakis]

Just got my Active with holster this past Saturday. Very nice fit and I like it a whole lot. Exactly as I imagined it. Not much bulk added at all. Feels real nice and very happy with it.

[jamjr74]

Just ordered my surface, friend has one for the EVO and it looks sweet.