I had the Otterbox defender and only used it for half a day......HUGE!!!!! Makes the damn phone look more like a tablet. If you like chucking your phone and don't mind the size, that baby will do the trick. I am now rocking the standard carbon look silicone case from the verizon store and it fits in the car dock, looks and feels awesome. I do need to push down harder to get the dock to engage the charge usb but other than that noooo problem!
If ignorance is bliss, why aren't there more happy people out there..........?
I'm going with the Otterbox Defender. I work in a harsh environment and need the most protection for my phones. I had a a Defender for the Droid X2 and that thing was solid as a rock. I just need to find a decent price on one, all the sites that sell at a good discount are out of stock at the moment.