i think a white "edge" type theme would be sick looking with some dark color to seperate it out
Yea that's a good point jbrock. One thing that kind of bugged me about DarkEdge was that in some areas everything kind of ran together. It would be cool to see some more strict delimiters (between keys on the keyboard type of thing).
Icculus, I personally think it looks clean and integrated. It's just my style and I've been doing it since I started designing. Try it some time! It's a bit harder (in my opinion) than "normal" themes/design, but it looks 10x nicer to me.
You obviously have no idea how hard it is to make paint splatters look good on a small screen.