I was about to post the solution but looks like you figured it out before I did. :)
Originally Posted by derekthorne
THAT DID IT!!!
When I went in and "unjoined" DREW and ANDY (still not sure why they were joined automatically as they were two seperate contacts in Gmail) it had them as two seperate contacts.
When I updated my FB information, it now has them as TWO SEPERATE contacts, each with their own number and FB profile!
I thought you had said you had already tried that? That was the first suggestion... anyway... glad it works now.