DroidForums.net is the original Verizon Android Forum! Registered Users do not see these ads. Please Register - It's Free!
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 18

Thread: Android Skins: Beautiful, or only skin deep?

  1. DF News Team
    This Green Machine's Avatar
    Member #
    103520
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Chicago
    Posts
    27
    Phone
    Motorola Droid (OG)
    Premium Member
    #1

    Android Skins: Beautiful, or only skin deep?


    (This is a guest post by Dave D. from ThisGreenMachine.com. The original article can be found at this link.)

    As T-Mobile announced itís new top tier Android smart phone (T-Mobile G2) on Thursday, I saw something I had not seen in a very long time. If you donít own an unmodded Droid or Nexus One you might not recognize the skin being used on the G2. Itís a bit modest in looks, and might lack a few features of itís relatives, but itís blazing fast and receives updates more quickly than others. You might have heard of it before Ė itís called stock Android 2.2 (Froyo).

    After the success/failure (depending on how you look at it) of the Nexus One, I didnít know if another stock Android device would be released until Android 3.0 (Gingerbread). Like a breath of fresh air, the T-Mobile G2ís most outstanding characteristic is itís clean taste. In a world filled with too many toppings and fillers, vanilla is my flavor of choice: comforting, familiar, and without unneeded calories.

    Donít get me wrong, I love that there are skins available to give the user a variety of options Ė not everyone prefers the stock experience. Personally, I have always been a man to choose function over form, and while most skins do improve certain aspects of the UI (e.g., media player, contacts), they also add bloat, not to mention significant lags in OS updates due to a need to tweak each skin. Take for instance the Droid 2. As previously reviewed, with a much faster processor than the Droid 1, we should have seen an increase in performance, but instead we found it to be sluggish and only slightly better. With only so many ways to design a slate device, manufacturers are veering away from their core competency (hardware), looking to differentiate on the soft side. A note to manufacturers: Let the coders code, and you stick to making great hardware.

    True to form, the Android community has responded to problems with the skin experience with the development of custom launchers. Are you using the latest Cyanogen Mod rom? Then you are probably using either Launcher Pro and ADW Launcher, which have gained notoriety due to their ability to be highly customized without all the bloat. But, this too has its flaws. As managing editor of Engadget, Nilay Patel, stated last week during Engadgetís weekly podcast: Do we really have to rely on a launcher created by some guy in his basement to give us the better Android experience than carriers and manufacturers?

    So whoís to blame? Many point the finger at Google for not better controlling the ecosystem. Comparisons of the market place to the wild west often ring true. In a strange twist of fate, Androidís best feature is also becoming its worst enemy: openness. By allowing carriers and manufacturers complete creative control, Android is quickly morphing into a road fragmented into many different paths.

    Hereís my solution. With the release of Android 3.0 (Gingerbread), any phones that include Google apps such as Gmail and the Market must ship with stock Android and stricter minimum hardware requirements. Google must work with manufacturers to develop existing skins into applications that can be downloaded and updated from the market. Smart phones can ship preloaded with a skin, but the user should be able to uninstall it if desired. Manufacturers will be allowed to limit access to skins to their devices.

    Sounds almost too simple, doesnít it? By effectively turning a skin like Sense UI into a large custom themed launcher, the user has the option of running stock on any device if they choose, and manufacturers get a differentiating edge. System updates will only be delayed from carrier tests, and skins can be updated later via the market. Yes, I realize that a minimum hardware requirement may initially contribute to fragmentation, but at some point, a hardware refresh is necessary in order to keep up with software advances. If the bar is set high enough, hardware will last for years instead of months.

    While there is no single, easy solution for such a large problem, many are hoping that Android 3.0 (Gingerbread) will be a big step in the right direction. Skins do bring variety to the Android experience, but also create a lot of baggage. Even with all of its quirks and issues, we have to give credit to Google for sticking to its guns. Under mounting pressure and backlash, Android remains as open as promised. Letís hope that carriers and manufacturers donít close the door.
    This Green achine: All Android, all the time.
    Real commentary on news that matters.
    www.thisgreenmachine.com
  2.  
     
     
     
  3. Senior Droid
    mattg1's Avatar
    Member #
    43275
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Franklin,Tn
    Posts
    161
    Phone
    Droid X
    #2
    I 100% agree I have been saying this since I first got my droid, let people choose if they want these skins. That's why I haven't upgraded because I cant get anything that compares to my OG droid with the vanilla experience (well that and my droid is still awesome).
  4. Super Moderator
    furbearingmammal's Avatar
    Member #
    78594
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    So far north in NY I smell maple syrup when the wind blows out of the west.
    Posts
    10,371
    Liked
    32 times
    Twitter
    @FurryVarmint
    Premium Member
    #3
    Gingerbread is supposed to be a game changer. Let's see if it turns into FroYo.

    I pray not.
  5. Droid Sensei
    Dave12308's Avatar
    Member #
    4889
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Posts
    3,274
    Liked
    209 times
    Phone
    Droid Bionic
    #4
    Quote Originally Posted by This Green Machine View Post
    As managing editor of Engadget, Nilay Patel, stated last week during Engadgetís weekly podcast: Do we really have to rely on a launcher created by some guy in his basement to give us the better Android experience than carriers and manufacturers?
    To answer Patel, YES, we SHOULD have to rely on a launcher "created by some guy in his basement" - that is the WHOLE spirit of Android, to begin with. Open development. The apps included in the Android OS are designed to provide base functionality, and not much more. If you want something better, you do it yourself; or use something that someone else has created.

    I think people are getting too caught up with the iOS type user experience, where basically, WYSIWYG. Stock Android may not offer the best OOB experience, but the customizability is where its true beauty lies.
  6. Senior Droid
    JonDenver'sCopilot's Avatar
    Member #
    72369
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Posts
    158
    Phone
    Droid
    #5
    Quote Originally Posted by Dave12308 View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by This Green Machine View Post
    As managing editor of Engadget, Nilay Patel, stated last week during Engadgetís weekly podcast: Do we really have to rely on a launcher created by some guy in his basement to give us the better Android experience than carriers and manufacturers?
    To answer Patel, YES, we SHOULD have to rely on a launcher "created by some guy in his basement" - that is the WHOLE spirit of Android, to begin with. Open development. The apps included in the Android OS are designed to provide base functionality, and not much more. If you want something better, you do it yourself; or use something that someone else has created.

    I think people are getting too caught up with the iOS type user experience, where basically, WYSIWYG. Stock Android may not offer the best OOB experience, but the customizability is where its true beauty lies.
    +1 Couldn't have said it better myself.
    Want to know the best way to root your Android device??? Try www.rootzwiki.com
  7. Droid Ninja
    tktouch12's Avatar
    Member #
    5909
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Posts
    1,247
    Phone
    HTC Droid Incredible 2
    #6
    i'd like to say i hate all the skins besides sense. i've used them all and i think sense really 'got it right' i like it better than stock or anything else.

    however, if you are on stock, launcher pro is a must. it is the best home replacement, is very customizable, and has great widgets that copy sense.
    got eris: 12/24/09
    returned eris: 12/28/09
    got droid: 12/31/09
    rooted droid: sometime in january (right after it was released (manually))
    bb->2.1 sbf->desire rom> 2.1bb> 2.2
    got incredible as warranty replacement 8/31/10
    shattered inc screen 9/25/10-> got insurace replacement 10/4/10
    broke inc screen 10/19/10-> got warranty replacement 10/22/10
    got moto droid 1 off ebay 1/7/11
    broke inc screen 5/26/11-> got insurance replacement inc2 5/27/11
    sold inc2 & bought vzw 16gb iphone 4 6/9/11
  8. Super Moderator
    Martin030908's Avatar
    Member #
    248
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Posts
    8,836
    Liked
    8 times
    Phone
    Galaxy S3
    Premium Member
    #7
    Gingerbread is gearing more toward Google apps being updated more thru the Market vs. using massive firmware updates. It's an attempt to consolidate the 'fragmentation'.

    Google will try to create a 'blanket' look but manufacturers (ie HTC, Samsung) will always add in their own UI's. I don't see individual UI's going anywhere. It's marketing for each manufacturer.
  9. Senior Droid
    Chris-pee's Avatar
    Member #
    16765
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    177
    Phone
    Bionic
    #8
    You need to have an option. Boot with/without the skin. Simple as that!
  10. Super Moderator
    Martin030908's Avatar
    Member #
    248
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Posts
    8,836
    Liked
    8 times
    Phone
    Galaxy S3
    Premium Member
    #9
    Quote Originally Posted by Chris-pee View Post
    You need to have an option. Boot with/without the skin. Simple as that!
    So simple it's brilliant, but we'll probably never get it
  11. Developer
    jamezelle's Avatar
    Member #
    57783
    Join Date
    Apr 2010
    Posts
    620
    Phone
    Motorola Droid
    DroidForums.net Developer
    Premium Member
    #10
    Quote Originally Posted by Dave12308 View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by This Green Machine View Post
    As managing editor of Engadget, Nilay Patel, stated last week during Engadgetís weekly podcast: Do we really have to rely on a launcher created by some guy in his basement to give us the better Android experience than carriers and manufacturers?
    To answer Patel, YES, we SHOULD have to rely on a launcher "created by some guy in his basement" - that is the WHOLE spirit of Android, to begin with. Open development. The apps included in the Android OS are designed to provide base functionality, and not much more. If you want something better, you do it yourself; or use something that someone else has created.

    I think people are getting too caught up with the iOS type user experience, where basically, WYSIWYG. Stock Android may not offer the best OOB experience, but the customizability is where its true beauty lies.

    I totally agree with you!!


    Roms: MIUI for Droid-1

    Like what I do? Feel free to
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Links

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Similar Threads

  1. Beautiful Widgets skins
    By Jim 777 in forum Android Applications
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: 08-07-2010, 01:49 PM
  2. No Skins Found in Beautiful Widget
    By saobi in forum Android General Discussions
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 05-03-2010, 08:41 PM
  3. beautiful widget skins download
    By futemadroid in forum Android Applications
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 05-03-2010, 06:40 PM
  4. Beautiful Widgets Unable to DL Skins
    By GrooveElements in forum Android Tech Support
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 04-18-2010, 10:19 AM
  5. beautiful Widgets skins problem.
    By pilot25 in forum Android Tech Support
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 02-21-2010, 01:52 PM

Search tags for this page

android skin app
,
android skin apps
,

best android skin

,
best android skin app
,

best android skins

,
best skin android
,
best skin for android
,
best skins for android
,
ios skin android
,
ios skin for android
Click on a term to search our site for related topics.
Find us on Google+