DroidForums.net is the original Verizon Android Forum! Registered Users do not see these ads. Please Register - It's Free!
Results 1 to 8 of 8

Thread: 4G Networks Compared - They 'Need More Time in The Oven', but Begin a Bright Future

  1. Administrator
    danDroid's Avatar
    Member #
    2
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Posts
    2,280
    Liked
    352 times
    Twitter
    droidforums
    Premium Member
    #1

    4G Networks Compared - They 'Need More Time in The Oven', but Begin a Bright Future


    Sometimes when a writer does research for a particular article, the facts that you uncover lead you inexorably to the realization that you really have a completely different story. This article is such a story. My original intent was to simply share with you a comparison and contrast article for the three major 4G networks that are available right now. Although the majority of that information will still be contained within this piece, our current "4G" networks aren't really 4G at all. They are more like 3.1G - 3.5G. Although even that turns out to be fairly subjective too and in the long run may not really matter at all.

    First, the following is a breakdown of the three major cellular networks' 4G Service features (for the purposes of this article I included the best 'bang for your buck' plans from each carrier instead of listing all of them):

    Sprint 4G WiMAX-
    • Launched in 2008 - Currently in 74 Cities (availability is limited)
    • Speeds - claims up to 10Mbps - real-world averages 3 to 6Mbps
    • Currently has two phones - the HTC EVO and Samsung Epic. For Mobile Broadband - 2 USB Dongle Modems and 2 Routers (for home computers)
    • Phone Plans - Unlimited Data (No Monthly Download Limit). Prices begin at $69.99 + $9.99 surcharge per month for 'Everything Data' plans
    • Mobile Broadband Modem Plans - Unlimited Data (No Monthly Download Limit). Price = $49.99 per month
    • Desktop Modem Connection Plan - Unlimited Data (No Monthly Download Limit). Price = $44.99 per month


    T-Mobile HSPA+-
    • Launched in March of 2010 - Currently in 80 Cities (availability is limited)
    • Speeds - claims up to 21Mbps - real-world averages 5 to 8Mbps
    • Currently has two phones - the myTouch 4G and the G2. For Mobile Broadband - 2 USB Dongle Modems and 1 Netbook
    • Phone Plans - Unlimited Data (but potentially reduced speeds if large usage impacts their network). Prices begin at $79.99 per month
    • Mobile Broadband Plans - 5GB per month access with reduced speeds when that limit is reached. Price = $39.99 per month


    Verizon 4G LTE-
    • Launched December 5th, 2010 - Currently in 38 Metro areas and 60 airports (availability is limited)
    • Speeds - claims up to 5 to 12Mbps - no real-world averages yet, but initial testing reports indicate 12 to 15Mbps on an unloaded network
    • Currently has no phones available yet. For Mobile Broadband - 2 USB Dongle Modems
    • Phone Plans & Mobile Broadband Plans are the same - $50 per month for 5GB per month - $10 per GB beyond the limit

    We can draw some conclusions from this data. First, Sprint offers the slowest speeds, but has the only truly unlimited data plan, and the cheapest price. Second, Verizon has the best speeds, but their plans are the most expensive. Their 4G plan is in addition to whatever phone plan you already have, and their data limitations could get very expensive. also, they have the most limited availability with no phones yet and very limited coverage. T-Mobile seems to have the best 'middle ground' of the bunch and the best coverage, but their plans are also the most complicated to figure out. Obviously, what is best for you can also be completely limited by what is available in your area. If you live in a rural area then you probably can not take advantage of any of these plans. Of course, these services are all very new and availability will change. It's also entirely probable that a price war will brew as more people start adopting the new technology.

    Regardless, there is a hidden secret underlying each and every one of these '4G' plans. They are not really '4G' at all. According to wikipedia.com the ITU Radiocommunicationsector (ITU-R), which is one of the three divisions of the International Telecommunications Union, is the organization whose purpose is "to manage the international radio-frequency spectrum and satellite orbit resources and to develop standards for radiocommunications systems with the objective of ensuring the effective use of the spectrum." This organization defines the specifications standard to be considered a 4G network as the following:

    • All-IP communications.
    • Peak data rates of up to approximately 100 Mbit/s for high mobility such as mobile access and up to approximately 1 Gbit/s for low mobility such as nomadic/local wireless access, according to the ITU requirements.
    • Scalable channel bandwidth, between 5 and 20 MHz, optionally up to 40 MHz.[5][5][6]
    • Peak link spectral efficiency of 15 bit/s/Hz in the downlink, and 6.75 bit/s/Hz in the uplink (meaning that 1 Gbit/s in the downlink should be possible over less than 67 MHz bandwidth)
    • System spectral efficiency of up to 3 bit/s/Hz/cell in the downlink and 2.25 bit/s/Hz/cell for indoor usage


    Wow! 4G is defined as 100Mbps. Even at their peak, which has not been achievable from any public testing I could find, the existing 4G networks only hit 20% of that.

    So, does this mean that we are being deceived and should be angry. It turns out, not really. According to this article at cnnmoney.com, Dan Hays, an industry management consultant at PRTM has this to say, "The labeling of wireless broadband based on technical jargon is likely to fade away in 2011," said Dan Hays, partner at industry consultancy PRTM. "That will be good news for the consumer. Comparing carriers based on their network coverage and speed will give them more facts to make more informed decisions." He further adds, "Historically, ITU's classification system has not held a great degree of water and has not been used to enforce branding," Hays said. "Everyone started off declaring themselves to be 4G long before the official decision on labeling was made. The ITU was three to four years too late to make an meaningful impact on the industry's use of the term."

    Hmmm... so, how are we to determine whether we are really getting what we paid for, if the only industry standards organization is practically ignored by the industry it was created to govern? Perhaps that is more of a philosophical or political question than a practical one.

    Of course in the ultra competitive world of high-speed cellular networks, the giants of the industry are going to come at us from all sides with marketing jargon. They improved their networks to offer dramatically faster speeds, and they had to call it something. Do they sometimes bend the truth... perhaps, and perhaps that makes for an interesting 'truth in advertising' discussion, or perhaps a 'how do we set industry standards' discussion? But, the bottom line is that these emerging technologies are just now beginning their evolution and, as it is with most technical industries, the early adopters have to experience the growing pains. These services are simply a bit 'under-done out of the oven' at the moment.

    In the long run this 'mythology' will simply shake itself out of the industry, and we will be left with an amazing new 'even more' digitally connected world. I don't feel duped. In fact, from my perspective I can only quote the song from the 80's band Timbuk 3, "The future's so bright... i gotta wear shades."


    by dgstorm
  2. Senior Droid
    neubanks89's Avatar
    Member #
    16335
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    130
    Phone
    Droid
    #2
    the phone plan prices for Verizon's LTE have not been announced yet and many sources confirm that it is different than the USB data-only plans.
  3. What iDoesn't
    Droid DOES!!'s Avatar
    Member #
    77093
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    6,335
    Liked
    47 times
    Phone
    Rezound and Bionic
    DroidForums.net Theme Developer
    Premium Member
    #3
    I can confirm this

    Quote Originally Posted by neubanks89 View Post
    the phone plan prices for Verizon's LTE have not been announced yet and many sources confirm that it is different than the USB data-only plans.


    DroidForums junkie!!
    "If you think you know everything, you can't learn anything." -Robert Morris

    If you like my work or I have helped you out and you would like to help me keep the lights on, it is greatly appreciated!!
    http://bit.ly/ro3alQ
  4. Master Droid
    gmorgan056's Avatar
    Member #
    80789
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Seattle, WA
    Posts
    451
    Liked
    9 times
    Twitter
    gmorgan056
    Phone
    Galaxy Nexus
    #4
    You know, I saw a similar article about this a few weeks ago on Yahoo!. I was not all that surprised to learn that these 4G networks aren't tecnically 4G.

    Another note, since the LTE network has been switched on, my 3G service here in Seattle has gone to crap. I'm not sure if it's my phone being dumb or if it has anything to do with the LTE.
    Rooted OG D1 running Liquid Gingerbread 2.6, Project Elite v6.5, Droid Concepts 12 and many more!
    Chevy No.1 Low V 1.1 Ghz Kernal

    A Droid Bionic evolved into a Rezound which then evolved into a Nexus! Running whatever Rom I'm feeling for the day.

    Questions about rooting: http://bit.ly/droot

    Sent from my Nexus in a Galaxy far, far away...
  5. Master Droid
    Bilgediver's Avatar
    Member #
    122836
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Location
    On Board a ship
    Posts
    919
    Liked
    6 times
    Phone
    Motorola Droid 1
    #5
    However, when things work out I might decide to get a Sprint WiMax 4G Modem, if only for the unlimited data plan. Its speeds should be more than adequate for anything I do, and much cheaper than anything Verizon puts out, especially since Verizon will NOT have an unlimited broadband plan. Really annoying since it is my PRIMARY MEANS OF INTERNET.
    Droid RAZR MAXX/ DROID 2 Global/ DROID 1 with DROID 2 EXTENDED BATTERY (BP7X - 1860 mAh)
    ICS /Stock 2.2/UltimateDroid 1.0.0
    Stock Kernel/ChevyNo1's ULowV 1.25 GHz kernel
  6. Junior Droid
    rtompkins3's Avatar
    Member #
    81085
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    10
    Phone
    HTC Thunderbolt
    #6
    I think this shows the current 4G USB modem plans:
    one for 5G and one for 10G, $10/gig overage on each:

    Verizon Wireless - Mobile Broadband - Plans

    As far as whether it's "true" 4G or not, it's a considerable improvement over 3G or 1XRTT :-).

    It also looks like the 3G USB modems are already gone from the available devices.
  7. Master Droid
    loki993's Avatar
    Member #
    136351
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Location
    Michigan
    Posts
    613
    Liked
    7 times
    Phone
    HTC Rezound
    #7
    Quote Originally Posted by neubanks89 View Post
    the phone plan prices for Verizon's LTE have not been announced yet and many sources confirm that it is different than the USB data-only plans.
    I hope that doesnt end up being correct, because Id really like to have LTE on Verizon whenever they decide to bring it here, but there is no way Im paying an EXTRA 50 dollars a month for it.
  8. Droid
    cjreyes666's Avatar
    Member #
    140749
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Posts
    49
    Liked
    3 times
    Phone
    Moto Droid
    #8
    odd since in other countries"4G" its actually called 3.9 or even 3.5

Links

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Similar Threads

  1. How to specify prefernce of WiFi networks?
    By ricks99 in forum Android Tech Support
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: 02-06-2012, 06:15 AM
  2. Wireless & Networks
    By jeter10 in forum Android General Discussions
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 11-01-2010, 03:37 PM
  3. Replies: 10
    Last Post: 04-28-2010, 09:52 PM
  4. 4G future (all networks)
    By huskur in forum Android Forum
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 03-11-2010, 11:54 PM
  5. Big Oven is now on Android Market
    By joeyspindler in forum Android Applications
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: 12-21-2009, 07:27 PM

Search tags for this page

4g comparisons
,

4g network comparison

,
4g network comparisons
,

4g networks compared

,
4g networks comparison
,
4g phone plans comparison
,

4g plan comparison

,
4g plans compared
,

4g plans comparison

,
4g service comparison
,

best 4g network in usa

,
compare 4g networks
,
compare 4g phone plans
,

compare 4g plans

,
comparison of 4g networks
Click on a term to search our site for related topics.
Find us on Google+