Does Voice Dial Suck or What?

[billyk]

I can't seem to get the native Google search to reliably make calls via voice with either 2.01 or 2.1. Is there a trick to this???

[SnoDrtRider]

Are you using Voice Dial or Google Search? Google Search works much better for me.

I also use Google Gesture Search (in the market) because I normally have a lot of background noise and spoken searches don't work well with the noise.

[aminaked]

Word, I haven't tried using it in over a month but I would go f-ing crazy trying to call anyone using that voicedial app. But I haven't seen many complaints about it. Maybe the software learns over time? Very weird. Dictating text into any text area works really well for me though!

[billyk]

The Voice Dial app just doesn't work for me. I was referring to the Google Search (long press on the hard button). Sometimes, it'll work - it dials perfectly. Other times it'll just produce a list of results. Other times it just doesn't know what to do.

I know not to voice dial in noisy locations, I talk clearly (I have no regional accent) and at a moderate tempo, and I say the proper command "Call Tom Smith, mobile" (when Tom Smith is the exact entry in Google Contacts).

Any advice? Any luck with 3rd party voice dial apps? I guess I have to investigate those, as voice dialing is really important to me.

[hookbill]

The Voice Dial app just doesn't work for me. I was referring to the Google Search (long press on the hard button). Sometimes, it'll work - it dials perfectly. Other times it'll just produce a list of results. Other times it just doesn't know what to do.

I know not to voice dial in noisy locations, I talk clearly (I have no regional accent) and at a moderate tempo, and I say the proper command "Call Tom Smith, mobile" (when Tom Smith is the exact entry in Google Contacts).

Any advice? Any luck with 3rd party voice dial apps? I guess I have to investigate those, as voice dialing is really important to me.

Using Voice Search on the phone is disastrous. But using the search button/microphone and saying "call home' or whatever seems to work great for me.

[billyk]

Thanks Bill. But I am a little confused. Doesn't:

- A long press on the hard search button
- A short press on the hard search button, then a press on the Mic
- Pressing the Mic on the "Google Search" widget
- Pressing "Voice Search"

... all get you to the same Google "Speak Now" search dialog box with the same functional (or dysfunctional!) behavior?

[hookbill]

Thanks Bill. But I am a little confused. Doesn't:

- A long press on the hard search button
- A short press on the hard search button, then a press on the Mic
- Pressing the Mic on the "Google Search" widget
- Pressing "Voice Search"

... all get you to the same Google "Speak Now" search dialog box with the same functional (or dysfunctional!) behavior?

Yes, it does. But if you go into contacts/menu/button/search you will see a microphone pop up on the keyboard. This is just for searching contacts and that's what I was referring to. Now that one never even comes close. Or if you go to the phone and then press the hard search key you will see it says search contacts. Same thing, doesn't work.

I'm saying just do it from the home screen. I'm pretty sure your correct about the widget, I don't use that anymore but I do thing that goes to the regular search.

Anyway my recommendation is hard button search, microphone on screen, say the person or business name, and it will find it for you.

[SnoDrtRider]

Thanks Bill. But I am a little confused. Doesn't:

- A long press on the hard search button
- A short press on the hard search button, then a press on the Mic
- Pressing the Mic on the "Google Search" widget
- Pressing "Voice Search"

... all get you to the same Google "Speak Now" search dialog box with the same functional (or dysfunctional!) behavior?

Voice Dial is within the phone... Search uses the network... I find the network works better.

[nogodiggydie]

I agree that the voice dial really sucks bad, but the Google voice search works surprisingly well. I use it all the time for navigation.

[gatorbait]

Voice dialing using Google's voice search commands has always worked flawlessly for me. (Long press on search soft button/Mic button on Google search widget).