I've had my Droid for 20 months now and just became eligible for an upgrade. I have been considering the X2, Inc2 or D3, leaning to one of the last 2. My Droid has been working without any problems for the entire time, except about a year ago it became very slow, but that was fixed with a factory reset and switching to Go Launcher EX.
As I research these phones I keep reading about all the problems that people are having with them. Are they really that bad? Both my Droid and my wife's Ally have been trouble free. They are not nearly as fast as the new phones, but at least they work all the time. Are all the problems with the new phones related to all the crap that the manufactures are putting on them, as opposed to the stock Android that is on our current phones. I know that I pretty much hate Blur, although HTC Sense seems better to me. The latest Inc2 update seems to have done nothing to fix the alarm and other problems.
Is there a phone on Verizon that works as well as the Droid? Forget speed. Speed does me no good if apps don't work - if my mail is screwed up or the alarm doesn't work or whatever.