this is not an impressive update.........I'll stick with BB......
I'm not sure this is all correct (Engadget = apple fanbois). If they kept the old app drawer tab at the bottom, how does the screen look? I'm not buying it and it actually sounds like a lot more work for Motorola to keep that from 2.01 than just update to 2.1. Same with the wallpapers, why not enable them?
A simple answer is the part of code this guy is testing is does not deal with graphic intense parts of Android, the drawer and wall papers are graphics intense and could be being implemented else where and then thrown all together in the end. Or Engadget is just bull****ting to attempt to piss Droid users off.
Last edited by iPirate; 02-08-2010 at 09:11 AM.
The only reason I was looking forward to this update was for the Live Wallpaper function....oh well, I really dont care when it comes out now.I'll get it when I get it.
My Dream Is To Be Your Worst Nightmare
-Tech_Nology_Pro on TWITTER
As with anything from Engadget, I'm taking this with a grain of salt.
In the event that they're correct and there is no revised drawer and no live wallpapers, I'll just root and get a 2.1 rom. Problem solved. Didn't have to have to root, but if we get screwed like that, I won't hesitate for a moment.
Just in case this could be true (I personally doubt it) that we don't get LiveWallpapers or the 3D app drawer. We should start to hit up MotoMobile on twitter to let them know this would not be acceptable and would cause us to reconsider purchasing Moto's phones in the future.
Maybe it's just me, but I tend to trust Boygeniusreport more than Engadget when it comes to Android/Google stuff. They are a little too apple-ish for me, and while BGR's apple bias is also quite clearly shown in, well, everything they write, they tend to get better leaks from what I remember.
While I hate to complain when all we have is a rumor that is unsubstantiated (in that even if Engadget posts it, I still don't believe it 'til i see it), I will say that the Nexus One on Verizon later this spring is looking ever more appealing. Maybe our GPU + CPU combination isn't as powerful as we think, and maybe the Snapdragon is that fast.
I would tend to trust Google on what a phone can/can't do more than people on this forum. The Sholes guys are no doubt amazing - I've seen videos of their ROMs and they make it easy for most of us to root. Without them, I think we'd all be complaining a lot more. But, if Google & Motorola feel that the Droid can't handle live wallpapers and the new launcher without bogging down the phone too much to properly run other programs, then I have to sit here and say they are right.
I guess I'll stick with an overclocked custom ROM for now and if the 2.1 update for the Droid is what Engadget's source says it is, if it passes testing and all of that jazz, then at least we'll all get a good (or hopefully good?) multitouch browser in our ROMs that is made to run natively on the Droid and not ripped from the milestone/Nexus One.
In any situation, without live wallpapers and the new launcher, I can't say the Droid will be, for me, as good as the Nexus One. I'd prefer a thinner phone anyway - not that the Droid is fat necessarily, as even for a slider it's super thin - but something thinner yet wouldn't hurt. Plus, the physical keyboard is completely useless to me. I just HATE HTC made hardware. Their home/back/menu/search keys on the bottom of the screen are just... crap. Motorola's Droid's keys are so much easier to press and when you press the center of them, they respond. HTC's you have to press a little above where the button is, close to the screen, to make it work. Well, that's how it works on the Droid Eris anyway.
Maybe the only hope someone like me has of getting the perfect combination of top-of-the-line Google support & truly best-in-class hardware (where the Nexus One is > the Motorola Droid) is waiting for Motorola to announce more details, including a launch date and a price for their Google.com/phone phone they are making, since it was revealed the "next Nexus One" type phone will not be made by HTC but instead by Motorola. Maybe just don't put a physical keyboard on this next phone...
Hmmm... I don't know about the rest of you, but it sounded fishy to me where it said that it's making its rounds through "Verizon's testing department". What would the new update have to do with Verizon? It's a Motorola phone, and the update is from Motorola not Verizon.
You would think that if it's being tested it would have been done by Motorola and not Verizon. The only thing I could see Verizon needing to test would be the OTA download/install, but that's about it.
Also the part where they saying we are keeping the 2.0.1 app drawer. Other than the 5 home screens the 3D app drawer is probably the biggest visual change in 2.1, so I don't really see Motorola not giving us that.
I call B.S. on these so called "news".