I got my screen protectors in the mail today and just got done installing. No air bubbles at all and can't even tell it is installed. 3 pack for $2.99, shipping was approx 3 days.
The screen protectors I purchased and the seller I purchased from:
3X LCD Screen Protector for VERIZON Motorola DROID A855 - eBay (item 290389469225 end time Jan-18-10 13:24:35 PST)
Attached are some pics of the protectors (also came with a small cleaning cloth). Sorry, no pics of it installed on my droid, honestly though you cant even tell there is anything on there so a pic wouldn't show anything.
But between the two in the OP I would go with Seidio. They make great products (I have the Innocase and Holster for the Droid and love them).
they work well - 1st time i've ever used a screen protector, didn't think i needed one but figured why not try since they were free , after all i can't tell its even on the Droid (don't use a case) with my wife's Eris, the edges keep a bubble because of the case that she has (pushed the edges)
note that she installed both, using a credit card to smooth out the bubbles and the very 1st try was on her Eris, it came out with too many bubbles, my Droid was next - came out well , then she put a second one on the Eris, worked well
it's been since the mid of Dec that we've been using the initial protectors, the guy at the store said they would last for a month, so it's been almost 1 month and both are holding up well (a tiny bit of the edges are peeling up on my Droid but not much, nothing you can even notice unless looking for it - nothing near the display portion)
i don't know if I'll buy replacements once these are gone (i think they are 10-packs) so that's gonna last for some time .....
based on my wife's 1st result with the Eris , it def depends on how well you apply - how careful you are (the 1st one she tried on the Eris had so many bubbles in the middle, it was awful)
I'm not a fan of the Zagg. Too tacky and no way to avoid the orange Peel. I had an Invisible Gadget Guard on my Samsung Impression and loved it. A little thinner than the Zagg but still protects as good. And it is very smooth. Barely know it is on there.
I have found the screen protectors by Box Wave to be the best. They are a little more expensive but well worth it. They have a couple of different type. I always get the Anti-Glare which also seems to be Anti-fingerprint. The best part is if they get really dirty you can take them off, wash them, and then put them back on.
BoxWave Accessories - iPhone, Blackberry, Treo, HTC Cases, Batteries, Chargers & More