Suffice to say that I went through a struggle to get a burgundy case with the embossed (non-white) logo on the back. On the plus side, Seidio made it right in the end and I'm quite happy with the case.
As far as different "castings" are concerned, I'm not surprised. I think Seidio has been through the wringer from their supplier(s) over the Droid Innocase. In my case, comparing the three cases I received, the color varied slightly from one to another. One had a "drilled" hole in the back, and two had square holes. And when I put this last version on, I noticed that the slight rise at the top of the back of the phone was less prominent than on the first and second cases I received. (The last one has the embossed logo.) All three of the cases I received fitted perfectly, but I suspect that's just the luck of the draw.
In short, I suspect that being a new product rushed to market to meet significant demand has resulted in some problems for Seidio. I've purchased several products from them over the years and this is the first I've had significant problems with. Still, they've straightened it all out in the end and I'm a satisfied customer.
I suggest that others with problems simply be firm, polite, and persistent. Seidio will get it right if it's possible to get it right. And that's not an insignificant point.
We bought our droids yesterday and preordered the seidio cases before buying the phones so that we had them to go on right when we bought the hardware. We bought one black case and one gray case. Both cases fit our phones perfectly. Love the phones and love the cases!
On two of my Droid's the case fits perfectly but on the third it doesn't . all of them are made on 49/09 but they all have different battery covers , sizes and sliding keyboards . Guess somebody messed up the mouldings dimensions for one of the production lines .
Just a heads up. Don't buy these 2nd hand from other users. I bought an Innocase second hand and the top doesn't fit. I called Seido and they will not send a replacement piece since I didn't buy it from an "authorised seller".